Skip to content
Notice

Dear Parents, Staff, and Community Members,

As the superintendent of our school district, I want to communicate directly with you about an important shift in how public education is evaluated in Missouri. In the coming weeks, you will begin seeing headlines and discussions regarding a new state-mandated A–F letter grading system for public schools. I would like to share some context so you can better understand how this impacts our school and community. This is a critical time for the future of public education, and it is incredibly important that our community remains well-informed.

What is the A–F Grading System?

Following an executive order and a framework approved by the Missouri State Board of Education, the Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE) has developed a performance grading scale for school districts. Under this model, every public school district and individual school building in the state will be assigned a single letter grade from A to F.

It is vital to note that these grades apply strictly to our school buildings and the district as a whole—they do not impact your individual student’s report card, GPA, or personal grades. The state’s formula calculates these grades based on a combination of factors, including academic achievement in math and literacy, academic growth, graduation rates, and College and Career Readiness indicators.

The vast majority of the data used to calculate these scores is derived from year-end standardized tests. Growth calculations made by the state have long been a point of contention for school leaders because our testing system does not naturally provide the necessary data to accurately support them.

DESE already has a system in place to grade school districts through the Missouri School Improvement Program (MSIP). This system has been used for many years, relying on the same data alongside other metrics to determine school accreditation and building-level performance. This information has historically been presented—and will continue to be presented—as the Annual Performance Report (APR). The new A–F system is entirely separate and carries an estimated taxpayer price tag of over $6 million.

Right now, the state is rushing this framework forward. While initially slated for a longer trial period, the state has accelerated the timeline, and the first public wave of these letter grades is expected to drop this December. I am reviewing our embargoed preliminary scores at this time and will share our results as soon as they are legally cleared for public release. Because these metrics rely on testing data from a couple of years ago, it is highly likely that the state's formulas will continue to be altered before final results are made public.

Beyond a Single Letter Grade

Educators are not critical of this new metric because we fear accountability or transparency. Every school leader and teacher I encounter—both here at Tri-County and across our neighboring communities—is deeply focused on continuous improvement. Our staff works tirelessly to help students grow from one day to the next. We collect data consistently to measure growth and identify learning gaps so that we can tailor instruction to exceed our goals. We are never content with the status quo, and our educators push our kids daily to be the best versions of themselves.

However, measuring the success of an entire school based on standardized testing alone does not do justice to everything we offer. Some children are simply not strong test-takers, and we regularly observe test anxiety when state assessments roll around. Furthermore, some students lack the motivation to perform their best on these exams because the results have zero impact on their personal grades or graduation eligibility.

Tests are only one narrow measure of student success. Extracurricular activities and school organizations serve to shape students by teaching public speaking, teamwork, discipline, and a strong work ethic. Much of the transformative work done in our schools goes well beyond a test score, meaning it won’t show up on this new state report card. Turnaround stories don't fit into an A-to-F box. Every year, I witness students make positive personal changes that completely transform their futures, driven by teachers and staff who refuse to give up on them.

A Concerning Trend for Public Schools

In my opinion, our schools need more structural support from Jefferson City rather than increased scrutiny. Tri-County receives the same amount of state funding today as it did in 2005. At that time, the split between local revenue and state revenue was approximately 50/50; today, our funding is heavily dominated by local revenue at a 2-to-1 ratio.

While funding has stagnated, bureaucracy has multiplied. The legislature has passed more education bills in the last six years than it did in the previous twenty. The compliance assurance statement I completed during my first year as superintendent was a single page; it is now three entire sections online. Years ago, we took End-of-Course (EOC) tests on paper and received results before the school year ended. Today, testing is entirely online, yet we don’t receive data until well into the summer. Our APR report used to be released before school started in the fall; now, we are lucky to receive it before January.

Alarmingly, state leadership is increasingly shifting its focus away from supporting public school districts. Legislators continue to push for public dollars to go toward private education, with the vast majority of those diverted funds flowing into suburban St. Louis. Those private schools will not be receiving a grade card. Meanwhile, the State Board of Education recently approved a budget request that intentionally underfunds the state education formula by $270 million—a deficit request that is unprecedented in my career.

This is the same State Board of Education that has struggled to maintain stable leadership to manage DESE. We have seen two education leaders depart within a six-month span. Recently, some lawmakers have even begun calling for extreme district consolidation. The Speaker of the House suggested that Missouri should collapse its more than 500 public school districts down to just 50 or 60. Keep in mind that Missouri has 114 distinct counties; a shift like this would devastate rural communities.

Our Commitment to Tri-County

Schools need support. We know we aren’t perfect, and we are working incredibly hard to do better. That unwavering commitment won’t change, no matter what system the state uses to judge us. Ultimately, we will never be satisfied with an arbitrary "A" or "B" grade if even one student in our halls isn't thriving. Our focus will remain on individual kids and helping them grow into successful, fulfilled members of our community.

Tri-County is fortunate to have tremendous local backing, and we do not take your support for granted. I only wish our schools were receiving that same level of commitment from the state level.

Please feel free to reach out to me at any time with your questions or concerns.

Sincerely,

David Probasco

Superintendent, Tri-County R-VII School District